Ardell | Lashes, Nails, Brows & Duo Glue

Press On Naked Soft Volume vs Press On Overlash: Which Is More Comfortable?

Press On Naked Soft Volume vs Press On Overlash: Which Is More Comfortable?

By Ardell | Lashes, Nails, Brows & Duo Glue | Published: 2026-08-07

Category: Comparisons

Compare Ardell Press On Naked Soft Volume and Press On Overlash for comfort, wear, and ease. Find out which lash style feels lighter and more natural for all-day wear.

When it comes to false lashes, comfort is king. No one wants to spend the day blinking against a heavy, scratchy band or feeling like their lashes might pop off at any moment. Ardell offers two popular press-on styles that promise ease and comfort: Press On Naked Soft Volume and Press On Overlash. But which one truly delivers on the comfort front? In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences in design, weight, flexibility, and wearability to help you decide which lash is your perfect match.

Both styles are designed to be hassle-free, but they cater to slightly different preferences. Press On Naked Soft Volume focuses on a barely-there, natural look with a flexible band, while Press On Overlash offers a more dramatic, full-volume appearance with a sturdy yet comfortable fit. Let's dive into the details to see which one wins for comfort.

Design and Weight: Barely There vs Full Volume

The most noticeable difference between these two lash styles is their design philosophy. Press On Naked Soft Volume is all about subtle enhancement. The lashes are crafted with a thin, flexible band that mimics the natural lash line, and the fibers are lightweight and softly curled. This makes them feel almost weightless on your eyes, ideal for those who want to forget they're wearing lashes at all.

On the other hand, Press On Overlash is designed for drama. The band is slightly thicker to support the additional volume, and the fibers are denser and more curled. While this doesn't necessarily mean they're uncomfortable, the extra material can be noticeable if you're not used to wearing heavier lashes. However, many users find that the sturdy band actually helps the lashes stay in place without shifting, which can be a comfort advantage in its own right.

  • Press On Naked Soft Volume: ultra-thin band, featherlight fibers, natural curl.
  • Press On Overlash: slightly thicker band, full-volume fibers, dramatic curl.

Flexibility and Fit: Which Molds Better to Your Eye Shape?

A comfortable lash must conform to the natural curve of your eye without poking or pulling. Press On Naked Soft Volume excels here because its band is incredibly pliable. It bends easily to fit a variety of eye shapes, from almond to round, without creating pressure points. This flexibility also makes application easier, as you can adjust the lash to sit perfectly along your lash line.

Press On Overlash, while less flexible, offers a more structured fit. The band holds its shape well, which can be great for those who prefer a lash that snaps into place. However, if your eye shape is particularly curved or deep-set, you might need to trim or gently bend the lash to avoid discomfort. In general, the Naked Soft Volume's flexibility gives it a slight edge in the comfort department for most wearers.

  • Try the lash on before applying adhesive to see how it contours to your eye.
  • If the band feels stiff, gently flex it a few times to increase pliability.

Wear Time and All-Day Comfort

Comfort isn't just about how the lashes feel when you first put them on—it's about how they hold up over hours of wear. Press On Naked Soft Volume is designed for extended wear, with a lightweight construction that minimizes fatigue. The flexible band also moves with your natural expressions, reducing the chance of the lash lifting or digging into your lid.

Press On Overlash, with its more substantial build, is also built to last, but some users report a slight heaviness after several hours. This is especially true if you're not accustomed to wearing dramatic lashes. That said, the secure fit of the Overlash can prevent the annoying sensation of a lash shifting or peeling, which is a common comfort complaint with lighter styles. Ultimately, your personal tolerance for volume will determine which feels better for all-day wear.

  • For long events, consider carrying lash glue for quick touch-ups.
  • If you have sensitive eyes, opt for the Naked Soft Volume to minimize weight.

Ease of Application and Removal

A lash that's easy to apply and remove automatically feels more comfortable because there's less fiddling and pulling. Press On Naked Soft Volume is a favorite for beginners because its flexible band adheres smoothly without gaps, and it lifts off gently at the end of the day. The lightweight fibers also mean less tugging on your natural lashes when you remove the strip.

Press On Overlash, while not difficult to apply, requires a bit more precision due to its size. The thicker band can be a little more stubborn to remove, especially if you've worn it for a long time. However, using a quality remover can ease the process. For those who prioritize a gentle, fuss-free experience, the Naked Soft Volume is the clear winner.

  • Always remove lashes with a dedicated remover to avoid damaging your natural lashes.
  • Store your press-on lashes in their original packaging to maintain their shape.

Both Press On Naked Soft Volume and Press On Overlash are excellent choices, but when it comes to pure comfort, the Press On Naked Soft Volume takes the crown. Its featherlight design, flexible band, and gentle wear make it the go-to for those who want to forget they're wearing lashes. If you crave volume and don't mind a bit of extra weight, the Overlash is a worthy contender. Ready to experience the comfort of Naked Soft Volume? Check out the Press On Wispies Natural for a similar feel, or explore other styles to find your perfect match.

Wispies
Wispies

Shop Related Products

Accent 301, 4-Pack

Accent 301, 4-Pack

$9.99 $19.99

Shop Now
Accent 318, 4-Pack

Accent 318, 4-Pack

$9.99 $19.99

Shop Now
Individuals, Knot-Free, Medium, Brown

Individuals, Knot-Free, Medium, Brown

$2.50 $4.99

Shop Now
TexturEyes 581

TexturEyes 581

$2.00 $3.99

Shop Now